Examine the complete exchange
Bring one marked task, the exact comment and the pupil's response. Ask what they thought the adult wanted. Separate receiving the message, interpreting it, performing the correction and applying the learning later. Check what happens when feedback is private, brief and linked to an understood goal.
Check teaching and delivery
Confirm that the relevant skill was taught and that staff supplied the planned support. A comment may be clear yet ask for something the pupil cannot do without further modelling. Review the pupil's preferred help route and any family information about similar tasks.
Test one practical change
For example, a history answer is marked “use evidence”. Staff show on a different answer how a quotation supports a claim, then invite the pupil to select evidence for their own point. The review records the pupil's choice and explanation, rather than whether they copied the adult's model.
Agree the next decision
Check corrected work, a fresh attempt, prompts and the pupil's experience. Keep useful supports, teach missing knowledge and revise comments that remain inaccessible. Record who will provide each action and what will be reviewed next rather than adding a general target to accept criticism.
Further reading
Sources and further reading
- EEF: teacher feedback principles, background for classroom preparation
- EEF: checking understanding to guide teaching
These sources offer background guidance. The classroom examples and review comparisons above are illustrative suggestions to adapt, not diagnostic tests or evaluated case studies.
Share this article
Know someone who would find this useful?