A secondary pupil may use a skill successfully in a familiar activity but not recognise when it would help elsewhere. School should check the original learning, identify what changes in the new context and teach the connection explicitly. The aim is flexible, informed use of knowledge, rather than assuming that success on repeated identical exercises will transfer automatically. Suitable prompts and worked examples can support this process while the pupil learns what remains the same across different tasks.
Check that the original skill is secure
Ask the pupil to demonstrate the skill in a familiar task and explain the relevant steps in an accessible way. Notice whether success depends on an adult hint, a visible answer or a repeated task layout. These supports may have been useful during teaching, but they change what staff can infer about independent understanding. Record the conditions of success before concluding that transfer is the only difficulty.
If the original learning is uncertain, reteach the necessary step. A pupil who copies a planning grid accurately may not yet understand how it helps organise ideas. Moving immediately to a different subject can add complexity before the strategy is understood. Avoid interpreting this as unwillingness to apply learning or a fixed inability to generalise. Classroom evidence should guide teaching rather than supply a diagnosis.
Identify what has changed
Compare the familiar and new tasks with the pupil. Changes might involve vocabulary, materials, response format, setting or the number of decisions required. Ask what looks the same and what seems different. The relationship may be clear to an experienced teacher while remaining hidden to a learner who focuses on surface features such as topic or page design.
For example, a pupil may plan a history paragraph successfully but not recognise that selecting relevant evidence can also help in another written explanation. The subject knowledge and argument still need teaching; transferring a plan does not replace those demands. Identify the useful shared principle without suggesting that all subjects require identical answers or that a generic template will solve every task.
Model the connection explicitly
Show how the existing skill applies to a new example. Explain why you chose it and what needs adapting. A teacher might identify the question, select relevant information and organise an explanation, while noting that the evidence differs from the previous lesson. Keep the demonstration short and connected to the actual task rather than offering a long general discussion about learning strategies.
Invite the pupil to identify one useful similarity before attempting a manageable part. Allow a visible model or prompt where appropriate. If they cannot explain the connection, clarify it through another example rather than simply telling them to use what they already know. The purpose is to make the relationship teachable, not test whether they can discover it without assistance.
Vary examples thoughtfully
Begin with a modest change that preserves the important structure. In mathematics, a different context may use a familiar relationship; in writing, another topic may require the same planning decision. Introduce changes deliberately so staff can see which demand creates difficulty. Varying the wording, layout, numbers and setting all at once can make the source of confusion difficult to identify.
Include contrasts where useful. Show an example in which the strategy fits and another where it does not, explaining the difference. A pupil needs to learn when an approach is appropriate as well as how to perform it. Avoid encouraging mechanical use of a template in every task. Flexible learning includes recognising a different demand and seeking teaching or another method when the familiar approach is unsuitable.
Plan opportunities across subjects
Coordinate with relevant teachers so the pupil encounters a small number of clear connections. Share the purpose and language of the strategy rather than requiring identical worksheets everywhere. Subject teachers should explain how it applies within their discipline. The supporting adult can help the pupil notice the connection, but should not become the only person who interprets every task for them.
For example, an agreed planning question might ask what information is needed before beginning. In science this could concern observations; in history it might concern evidence from a source. Teachers should teach those distinctions explicitly. The pupil can then practise selecting relevant information within each subject, with appropriate feedback. A shared prompt is useful only if it supports real thinking about the content.
Make prompts available and review their use
Agree a cue that helps the pupil recognise the opportunity to use the skill. It might be a brief question, example or accessible reference. Teach the pupil where to find it and how it helps. Check whether the cue reveals understanding or merely produces a familiar action without meaning. Avoid treating a displayed resource as an adjustment delivered if nobody has introduced it.
Adjust prompts in response to learning rather than removing them according to a fixed schedule. Some aids may remain useful access arrangements. Ensure a reliable help route when the task changes or the pupil becomes unsure. Absence of adult help is not evidence of successful transfer if the pupil sits without understanding or guesses a response to avoid attracting attention.
Review use after a gap and on another example
Check whether the pupil recognises a relevant opportunity later, selects the approach and uses it accurately with appropriate support. Ask them to explain why it fits, using a suitable response mode. Include effort and participation alongside the finished product. If transfer remains limited, revisit skill security, task knowledge and the clarity of the connection with the SENCo where appropriate. Useful progress is purposeful application across relevant situations, rather than completion of a larger number of nearly identical exercises.
Further reading
Use these resources alongside knowledge of the individual pupil, family and school context.
Share this article
Know someone who would find this useful?