How can schools evaluate their checks of intervention fidelity?

Judge whether delivery checks identify meaningful variation and lead to useful support. More observations or completed checklists do not automatically produce a more accurate picture of intervention delivery.

Check the definitions first

Ask two trained colleagues to interpret the same essential teaching component. If they disagree about what counts, clarify the guidance with reference to programme materials and training. Avoid scoring vague qualities that observers cannot recognise consistently.

Examine the sampling

Compare observations across sessions, practitioners and stages of the programme where feasible. A specially prepared demonstration may not reflect ordinary delivery. Balance a proportionate sample with records of missed sessions and known interruptions.

Follow a finding through

For example, checks may identify that pupil practice is repeatedly shortened. Look for a practical response, such as protecting session time, and then see whether practice is restored. A repeated concern with no follow-up suggests the checking process is not yet useful.

Keep outcome evidence separate

Review whether delivery becomes more consistent, while checking learning through appropriate tasks. Improved fidelity records are not proof of improved attainment. Ask practitioners whether feedback is specific and usable, and simplify checks that create workload without changing decisions.

Further reading

Further reading

This source provides wider teaching guidance. The examples and review suggestions above are original classroom illustrations to adapt, rather than evaluated programmes or diagnostic tests.

More practical advice: Browse the advice.

Share this article

Know someone who would find this useful?