How do we know whether support for checking mathematical work is working?

Mathematical checking support is useful when pupils make more accurate judgements about their answers, correct relevant errors and explain the reason with less unnecessary adult help.

Specify the check taught

Choose a recurring issue, such as a missed unit or an implausible calculation. Record the pupil's starting response on suitable work. Different checks require different knowledge, so one overall score for checking may conceal what changed.

Compare noticing and repair

After teaching a check, use a fresh example and note whether the pupil detects a mismatch, explains it and corrects the work. If they cannot judge why an answer is wrong when shown, revisit the mathematical concept rather than treat the issue as insufficient attention.

Include appropriate acceptance

Offer correct examples as well as errors. A pupil who changes a correct answer because they assume the teacher expects a mistake has not yet established a useful judgement. Record support and avoid counting every correction as progress.

Review ordinary application

Look at another comparable task and whether the pupil chooses the check without an adult identifying the target. Include completion and effort so checking does not become endless repetition. Keep a concise reference where it enables control of the routine. Use persistent difficulties to refine teaching with the teacher or SENCo, not to demand more checking of the same misunderstood material.

Further reading

Sources and further reading

These sources offer background guidance. The classroom examples and review comparisons above are illustrative suggestions to adapt, not diagnostic tests or evaluated case studies.

More practical advice: Browse the advice.

Share this article

Know someone who would find this useful?