How do we know whether support for coping with mental maths is working?

Review whether the pupil calculates accurately, understands the chosen strategy and can use it on another occasion. A faster response to a rehearsed set is useful evidence, but does not by itself show that mental maths support is working.

Specify the learning being reviewed

Define a manageable target such as deriving an addition from a known double or adjusting a calculation near a multiple of ten. Record the pupil's starting strategy and the support available. A broad aim to improve mental maths makes it difficult to interpret a score.

Keep access conditions clear. Note whether the numbers stayed visible, a jotting was allowed or an adult repeated the question. These adjustments may be useful, but results under different conditions should not be treated as identical measures of unaided recall.

Compare a taught and a fresh example

If teaching has used 29 + 16 as 30 + 16 − 1, ask the pupil to explain why one must be subtracted. Then offer 39 + 24 with enough thinking time. Correctly choosing and explaining the adjustment is stronger evidence of strategy use than repeating 45 from memory.

Listen for a valid alternative method too. A pupil who partitions tens and ones accurately should not be marked unsuccessful simply because they did not select the teacher's preferred route.

Look again after a gap

Revisit the relationship during a later lesson and in a short practical question. Record accuracy, method, assistance and effort. A pupil may understand a strategy during supported practice but need further rehearsal to retrieve it without a reminder.

Ask what the pupil experiences: do they have a route into the calculation, or are they guessing to keep pace? Avoid public speed comparisons as the only review activity, particularly when those conditions obscure what the pupil knows.

Make a teaching decision

Continue an approach that supports accurate, increasingly usable reasoning. If errors persist, identify whether the difficulty lies in the number relationship, selecting it or keeping track of the calculation. Reteach that part or retain a helpful access adjustment rather than merely increasing the quantity of timed questions.

Put this into practice: Review accuracy, explanation, later retention and support together.

Sources and further reading

The sources provide wider guidance. The classroom examples here are illustrations to adapt and review, rather than evaluated cases or guarantees of benefit.

More practical advice: Browse the advice.

Share this article

Know someone who would find this useful?