Choose a useful starting point
Notice whether adults clarify access to the text or inadvertently supply the interpretation being assessed. Keep a few ordinary work samples and note the task, support and pupil view before changing the plan.
Test the intended change
Model rereading, identifying a clue and explaining an inference without completing the pupil's next answer. Use a prompt such as 'Which sentence helped?' and allow thinking time before offering a more specific cue.
Make the review actionable
Record the least prompt needed and whether the pupil can justify an answer on a fresh passage. Agree a short review period with the pupil and compare similar opportunities. Continue an accessible aid when it enables participation; if results are mixed, check that staff used it as planned before increasing or stopping the intervention.
Distinguish access support from supplying an answer
An adult can help a pupil access reading without taking over the interpretation. Reading a difficult instruction aloud, explaining an unfamiliar word or showing how to locate a paragraph may be appropriate. Telling the pupil which character is being deceptive or which sentence proves the answer supplies part of the reasoning. Decide what the task is intended to assess or teach, then identify the boundary. The same prompt can be useful during modelling and unsuitable as evidence of independent comprehension.
Observe a short interaction and record the adult's words as well as the pupil's answer. Notice whether a question contains the answer, whether the adult rejects alternatives before the pupil explains them and whether the adult's intonation signals the preferred choice. This is a review of the interaction, not a criticism of a teaching assistant trying to keep a lesson moving. Staff need a shared plan that makes it possible to provide access while preserving the pupil's opportunity to think.
Identify the minimum helpful prompt
Begin with a genuine question and sufficient thinking time. If the pupil is stuck, ask what is unclear or invite them to locate relevant information. Move to more specific support when needed, but record the change. Avoid following a rigid prompt ladder when the pupil plainly does not understand a word or concept. Accurate explanation and teaching may be required. The aim is not to withhold help; it is to understand which part of the answer the pupil can generate and which part still needs teaching.
Choose prompts linked to the observed difficulty. A pupil who loses their place may need a line guide or clear paragraph marker. A pupil who reads accurately but does not connect ideas may need explicit modelling of that reasoning. A pupil who cannot decode key words needs appropriate reading instruction and current access support. Asking every pupil to find a clue will not solve every reading barrier, and a generic prompt should not replace a precise understanding of the task.
Teach the strategy openly before checking independence
Model your reasoning with an example separate from the one the pupil will later answer. Explain how you reread, connect evidence and check whether an interpretation fits. Show uncertainty and how to resolve it, rather than performing an apparently effortless answer. Then provide guided practice with feedback. When checking independent use, offer a fresh passage or question so that success cannot be explained simply by remembering the modelled answer.
Keep suitable aids available and explain their role. A glossary, accessible text or reading technology may remove a barrier without supplying comprehension. Independence can include selecting and using those aids. Distinguish them from an adult paraphrase that has already identified the main inference. Record the support accurately so that a future teacher does not assume the pupil can read or interpret a passage under conditions they have never managed.
Review the reasoning behind the response
Ask the pupil what in the text supports their answer and how it connects to the question. Accept an accessible explanation, pointing or marking when spoken or written formulation is difficult. Avoid treating a grammatically polished answer as the only evidence of understanding. Also consider plausible alternatives. Some questions permit more than one supported interpretation, so do not guide the pupil towards one teacher-preferred phrase when their reasoning is defensible.
For example, an adult asks whether a character is worried, then points to a sentence about shaking hands and asks again. A correct answer after this sequence does not show that the pupil independently inferred worry. In teaching, the adult could model that link on one example, then ask the pupil to interpret a different passage. At review, note the support needed to locate evidence and explain its meaning rather than counting only correct responses.
Make classroom conditions support the approach
Agree how much time the task allows and what happens if a pupil needs more teaching. Pressure to finish every question can encourage adults to supply answers inadvertently. Class teachers should identify essential questions, share relevant learning goals and provide accessible materials. Teaching assistants need permission to report a barrier rather than produce a completed sheet. Review whether the pupil is participating in the teacher's instruction as well as working successfully beside an adult.
Compare fresh examples across occasions, recording prompts and the quality of justification. If the pupil needs less content supplied and can explain a new answer, support is moving towards greater control. If success occurs only with the same adult or text, teach transfer deliberately. If comprehension remains insecure despite accessible reading and appropriate teaching, discuss the wider evidence with relevant staff or specialists. A quiet completed worksheet is insufficient evidence that the pupil remains responsible for the thinking.
Give feedback about the pupil's action, such as returning to a sentence or revising an interpretation after checking evidence. This helps make the strategy available next time. Avoid praise that implies asking for clarification is a failure. A reader who recognises an uncertainty and obtains a useful explanation may be exercising more control than one who copies an adult's confident answer without understanding it.
Sources and further reading
- EEF: Improving Literacy in Key Stage 2
- EEF: The Guide to Inclusive Teaching
- DfE: The reading framework
- EEF: Special Educational Needs in Mainstream Schools
These sources inform the wider approach. The classroom example illustrates practice; it is not a research case study.
Share this article
Know someone who would find this useful?