Should our SENCo use coloured overlays for reading?

Coloured overlays should not be described as a treatment for dyslexia or other specific learning difficulties. Some pupils report visual comfort benefits, but claims about reading improvement require careful qualification.

Clarify the concern

Ask about discomfort and the circumstances in which it occurs, and discuss persistent symptoms with the family and an appropriate eye-care professional. Do not use a preferred colour as a school diagnosis of 'visual stress'.

Keep a trial proportionate

If a pupil wishes to try an inexpensive overlay, compare comfort, understanding and practical use with ordinary accessible formatting. Avoid expensive commitments or promises of improved attainment. The College of Optometrists describes the evidence and claims about tinted interventions as controversial.

Protect effective teaching

Continue assessment and teaching of decoding, fluency and comprehension where needed. Review whether the aid is comfortable and useful in normal lessons, and stop if it adds difficulty. An aid preference does not establish the cause of a reading difficulty.

Separate comfort, reading and claims about treatment

A coloured overlay may be preferred by an individual pupil, but preference does not establish why reading is difficult or show that an underlying learning difficulty has been treated. Begin with what the pupil reports and what staff observe. Distinguish visual discomfort, losing place, word-reading errors, slow fluency and difficulty understanding language. These can coexist and need different responses. Avoid presenting an overlay as a general dyslexia intervention or allowing a colour choice to replace an appropriate literacy assessment.

Current professional guidance requires care with claims about tinted interventions and specific learning difficulties. School staff should not diagnose visual stress through a brief overlay trial or promise improved attainment. If the pupil reports persistent discomfort, headaches or other visual symptoms, discuss appropriate eye-care advice with the family. A pupil can have a conventional visual problem alongside a literacy difficulty. Addressing one does not remove the need to understand and teach the other.

Check ordinary access features first

Look at print size, spacing, contrast, glare and page organisation. Ask whether the pupil can see relevant material comfortably from their position. Clearer formatting or a simple line guide may address a practical barrier without a coloured sheet. Do not suggest symptoms or imply that every pupil with dyslexia should experience visual distortion. Listen to the pupil's own account and record the circumstances in which discomfort arises.

Keep any trial inexpensive and proportionate, with no pressure to select a special colour or continue. Explain that the pupil can compare comfort and practical use without committing to a diagnostic explanation. Avoid costly purchases or a sequence of commercial tests based solely on a classroom preference. Where specialist advice is sought, use appropriately qualified professionals and current guidance. School can support access while remaining honest about what a simple trial can and cannot show.

Use a fair comparison

Choose short comparable reading material and note familiarity, difficulty and adult help. Repeated reading of the same passage can improve performance through practice, so do not attribute every increase in speed to the overlay. Include understanding and the pupil's sense of effort. A quicker reading with poorer comprehension is not the goal. A temporary effect on one task is limited evidence and should not be converted into a broad claim about long-term reading attainment.

Let the pupil describe whether the sheet is comfortable, distracting or awkward. Check reflection, movement and whether it obscures diagrams or annotations. An overlay may be easy to use on a flat worksheet but difficult with a small book or several resources. Consider whether handling adds a physical or organisational demand. The practical decision should concern worthwhile access in real lessons rather than performance in a highly controlled selection exercise.

Continue the reading teaching that is needed

Assess and teach decoding, fluency, vocabulary and comprehension as appropriate. Do not delay systematic instruction while waiting to see whether a colour solves the difficulty. A pupil who misreads taught correspondences needs suitable teaching and review, even if an overlay feels comfortable. Current access to worthwhile content can be supported through accessible texts, reading assistance or appropriate technology alongside that teaching.

For example, a pupil says pale print on a crowded worksheet is uncomfortable. Clearer formatting and a chosen inexpensive overlay may make the page easier to use. Record that practical experience without concluding the pupil has a diagnosed condition. If decoding remains insecure, continue explicit reading support. Another pupil chooses a colour but finds it cumbersome during lessons and stops using it. Respect the response and reconsider the actual access barrier rather than insisting the aid must work.

Review the decision without inflated expectations

Ask whether the pupil still wants the aid and whether it is available and manageable when needed. Review ordinary reading, not only a demonstration immediately after selection. If it adds difficulty or offers no worthwhile benefit, stop or adapt it. If the pupil finds a low-cost option comfortable, that preference can be accommodated without describing it as a proven treatment. Keep the explanation accurate for family and staff so that expectations remain realistic.

Record any professional advice and clarify which recommendations concern eye care, classroom formatting and literacy teaching. These should not become confused in a pupil passport or intervention record. A statement that an overlay is used should not lead future staff to assume the reading difficulty has been addressed. Keep the underlying educational goals and review evidence visible, with relevant specialist input where persistent concerns remain.

The useful outcome is comfortable, meaningful access to reading with an appropriate teaching plan. It is not successful colour selection, an expensive purchase or a faster score interpreted without context. Respect the pupil's experience while being clear about uncertainty and the limits of school observation. This supports practical choice without making unsupported claims or diverting attention from the reading skills that still need teaching.

Keep the decision proportionate

Write a brief practical record of what the pupil found comfortable, which task was tried and what remains uncertain. Do not convert that note into a diagnosis or a promise about attainment. If a low-cost preference is retained, state that explicit reading teaching continues and that persistent symptoms require appropriate professional advice. If it is not useful, explain the decision without suggesting the pupil failed the trial. The record should prevent future staff mistaking an ordinary aid preference for a settled explanation of the reading difficulty.

Sources and further reading

These sources inform the wider approach. The classroom example illustrates practice; it is not a research case study.

Share this article

Know someone who would find this useful?