Replace vague standards
“Do your best” can leave the endpoint unlimited. Show the essential criteria and explain which details matter now and which belong in later editing. Ask the pupil which parts they feel compelled to repeat. Check whether they need teaching in the skill being judged, such as handwriting or sentence construction.
Keep ambition in the ideas while making completion possible. Avoid praising long hours or immaculate work without noticing distress, missed learning or repeated restarting.
Model a usable stopping decision
For example, a teacher shows a draft explanation containing the correct scientific idea but awkward wording. They identify one change that makes the meaning clearer and leave a cosmetic improvement for later. The pupil applies the agreed criteria to their own draft and discusses one unresolved question at a predictable feedback point.
Use a stopping cue only with a clear explanation and the pupil's understanding. Taking work away unexpectedly or publicly exposing an imperfection may increase the barrier.
Review the cost of the product
Consider whether the pupil can submit meaningful work, move on and use feedback without repeated loss of their first attempt. Ask how effortful this feels. Persistent perfectionism that substantially restricts school life warrants discussion with family and the SENCo and appropriate further advice, even when the finished work is strong.
Sources and further reading
These sources offer background guidance. The classroom examples and review comparisons above are illustrative suggestions to adapt, not diagnostic tests or evaluated case studies.
Share this article
Know someone who would find this useful?