What might make it difficult when a friend plays with someone else?

A friend choosing another playmate can feel like rejection, especially when a pupil has few alternatives. Support the disappointment while teaching that friendships can include other people.

Understand what the pupil believes happened

Ask privately what they noticed and what they thought it meant. “She played with someone else” may have become “She never wants to be my friend again”. Check the actual interaction and whether there has been exclusion, teasing or a repeated pattern that adults need to address.

Avoid dismissing the feeling with “Just find another friend”. A pupil may not know how to join another activity, may dislike the available choices or may rely on a single trusted peer to make play predictable. Their account helps identify what support would be practical.

Explain friendship without promising exclusivity

Use a simple story or familiar example to show that enjoying one person’s company does not prevent playing with others. Discuss the difference between a friend making another choice today and someone behaving unkindly. Keep the message concrete, rather than requiring the pupil to accept a broad reassurance immediately.

Model language such as “Can we play together later?” and practise accepting an uncertain answer. Do not require the friend to provide constant reassurance or agree a fixed rota of companionship. Peers also need freedom to make ordinary social choices without being responsible for another pupil’s emotional regulation.

Prepare an alternative that the pupil wants

Before break, identify one or two activities the pupil actually enjoys and how to access them. Practise approaching the activity or asking an adult for help. A usable alternative is more helpful than a list of children they have been told they ought to play with.

For example, if the friend chooses football, the pupil might join a construction area with a known entry task. An adult can help the first approach and then step back. Keep support discreet, and do not describe the alternative activity as a consolation for being unwanted.

Review flexibility and quality of experience

Notice whether the pupil can express disappointment safely, choose another activity and reconnect with the friend later. Do not count being alone as failure if the pupil has chosen a satisfying solitary activity. Ask how break felt, rather than relying only on the absence of visible distress.

If the same pupil is persistently excluded or targeted, use the school’s response to bullying and peer concerns rather than treating the issue solely as their lack of resilience. Review supervision and opportunities for shared interests, while continuing to respect everyone’s choices about friendship.

Put this into practice: Plan one enjoyable alternative before break. Afterwards, ask what happened, what the pupil chose and whether they could reconnect with their friend without pressure.

Further reading

This source provides wider guidance. The classroom examples above are practical suggestions to adapt and review, rather than a prescribed programme or a guarantee of benefit.

More practical advice: Browse the advice.

Share this article

Know someone who would find this useful?