Check the whole writing process
Observe idea generation, sentence formulation, dictation, punctuation and editing separately. Speech recognition may reduce transcription demands while leaving planning or language difficulties unchanged. Ask whether the pupil can recognise when the software has recorded the wrong word and whether they can correct it without an adult taking over.
Examine real classroom conditions
Review microphone access, noise, privacy, set-up time and the pupil's comfort speaking work aloud. Provide teaching in manageable steps and retain another recording method when dictation is unsuitable. CALL Scotland emphasises that speech recognition requires skills and support; it is not an automatic solution for every learner. Classroom use does not itself establish permission for an examination.
Look beyond the first successful trial
A pupil dictates a strong explanation in a quiet room but loses the thread while correcting errors in class. The team provides a planning card, teaches one editing routine and trials a workable quieter position. They compare whether the final paragraph expresses the pupil's ideas and how much adult correction it needs, rather than counting dictated words.
Decide what to retain or change
Include the pupil's judgement of effort, embarrassment and control over their work. Compare similar tasks and note the support provided. If dictation shifts the difficulty to proofreading or repeatedly produces inaccurate work, adapt the teaching or use another method for that task. Continue explicit writing instruction alongside access support.
Further reading
This source provides background guidance. The examples and review suggestions above are original classroom illustrations to adapt, rather than evaluated programmes or diagnostic tests.
Share this article
Know someone who would find this useful?