What should school understand about double empathy?

Understanding double empathy helps staff distinguish the pupil’s access needs from assumptions about motivation or ability. When an interaction breaks down, ask what each person understood and what information was missing.

The double empathy problem is an idea about mutual understanding. It proposes that when people have different ways of communicating and experiencing the world, each can find the other hard to read. Damian Milton introduced the idea in relation to interactions between autistic and non-autistic people. In school, it can prompt staff to consider what both people understood and how the setting affected the exchange. It does not tell staff what happened in a particular incident or remove the need to address harm. Use it to ask better questions about communication and access.

Look at what both people understood

Consider a classroom instruction such as “Can you tidy that up?” The teacher may mean that several items should be put away. A pupil may think “that” refers to one object the teacher was looking at. The adult sees that only one item has moved and interprets it as reluctance. The pupil thinks they have followed the instruction and is surprised by a correction. Ask what the teacher intended, what the pupil understood and which cues were available to each. A clearer description of the action can resolve the immediate problem.

Listen to the pupil’s account of an interaction and give them a way to clarify their meaning. A pupil who looks away may still be listening. A peer who stops talking may be waiting for a reply. Check what each person expected rather than treating one style of eye contact, timing or expression as evidence of understanding. Give the pupil time and an accessible communication method. Avoid assuming that a particular behaviour always means the same thing or that all autistic pupils communicate alike.

Consider what the research can tell you

The original double empathy paper proposed a way of thinking about social difficulties as relational. Later studies have examined communication and rapport in different combinations of autistic and non-autistic participants. One adult study by Crompton and colleagues found differences in how rapport was rated according to the pairing. Such findings can inform questions about mutual understanding. They do not establish how a particular pupil or class will interact, and studies with adults cannot be directly generalised to every school situation. Consider the pupil, the people involved and the context.

The idea can help staff examine their own communication. Ask whether an instruction relies on an implied meaning, an unexplained gesture or knowledge of a social routine. Check whether the pupil can use their agreed communication support. Consider whether peers know how to invite a contribution or wait for a response. A pupil may also want to learn strategies for interpreting messages or asking for clarification. Teaching can give everyone more ways to understand one another.

Change a practical part of the interaction

Make important information explicit. Name the action, check what the pupil heard and show how they can ask a question. Where the meaning is genuinely open, invite people to say what they understood before choosing a response. Teach phrases such as “Which part do you mean?” and “I thought you were asking about this one.” Use written or visual support when it makes an exchange easier. Give people time to respond and check that the pupil can use their preferred way to communicate.

In a Year 8 example, a pupil and partner disagree about why their joint work stopped. The partner says the pupil ignored a suggestion, and the pupil says they thought the partner was still deciding. The teacher asks each to explain what they saw and heard. They agree that suggestions will be named directly and each person will confirm the next action before moving on. The pupil also asks to write a short note if they need time to respond. In the next task both pupils have a way to contribute and can check a misunderstanding before it affects the work.

Some misunderstandings involve different expectations about how to show interest. One pupil may ask several direct questions and think they are showing enthusiasm. A partner may hear the questions as criticism. An adult can help each say what they meant and agree a simple way to check how the exchange is going. The aim is to clarify what both people understood and give them a choice about how to continue. Ask whether the new wording or pause feels helpful to both.

Review participation and respond to harm

Look at whether people understand the instructions, can clarify uncertainty and have meaningful opportunities to participate. Ask the pupil what helped and how much effort it takes. A quieter exchange may still leave someone unsure what was meant. Check whether a change is available in the settings where it matters. If there is bullying, harassment, discrimination or a safeguarding concern, follow the school’s relevant procedures. Mutual misunderstanding can be one possibility and must not be assumed when there is evidence of harm or a power imbalance.

Discuss ongoing difficulties with the pupil, family and relevant staff, including the SENCO or equivalent lead where appropriate. Look at language, sensory access, relationships, previous experiences and communication support. One observation cannot explain all differences in communication. Keep agreed adjustments in place and consider relevant advice if a pupil repeatedly cannot express or understand essential information.

For the next interaction, ask what each person needs to understand and what would make that meaning clearer. Give the pupil an accessible way to check or respond. Review whether both people can continue with the task or conversation. A practical application of the idea helps adults and pupils share responsibility for making communication work, while staff retain their responsibilities for access and safety.

Sources for this article

Related classroom guidance

Try this: Choose one recurring situation connected with double empathy. Write down what happens before it, what the pupil appears to find difficult, the adjustment adults will make and one observable sign that access has improved.

Work with families and other professionals

Review the response to should school understand about double empathy using a short before-and-after comparison. Look across more than one occasion and include the pupil’s view where possible. A strategy is worth keeping when it produces a meaningful improvement in the intended outcome, not merely because adults feel busy or the pupil appears compliant.

Questions for the SENCo

Further reading

Use these sources alongside current statutory guidance, professional advice and the individual pupil’s circumstances.

More practical advice: Browse the advice.

Share this article

Know someone who would find this useful?