Avoid using achievement or gender as a screening shortcut
A high-attaining girl may have strong subject knowledge and still experience substantial difficulties with communication, organisation, sensory access or another area of school life. Her results deserve recognition, while any specific concern deserves investigation. Neither being a girl nor achieving highly establishes SEND. Equally, polite behaviour and good marks should not automatically close a discussion about needs. Start with the pupil's actual educational experience rather than a profile adults expect her to fit.
For schools in England, the SEND Code of Practice warns against assuming that age-appropriate attainment means there is no learning difficulty or disability. Apply the relevant national framework when considering identification and provision. School staff should not diagnose from a pattern of achievement and effort, and a general article cannot determine an individual pupil's legal or administrative status. Clear classroom support can proceed while the SENCo and relevant professionals explore unresolved questions.
Look at the route to success
Ask how work gets completed. Does the pupil repeatedly seek reassurance, spend disproportionate time reconstructing instructions or rely on extensive adult organisation? Distinguish a temporary response to a difficult assignment from a persistent barrier across suitable tasks. Check the quality of instructions and workload too. An unnecessarily complicated school system can create difficulty without the pupil having an underlying special educational need.
Review areas that attainment tests may not capture. These can include participation in practical lessons, understanding group-work expectations, coping with noisy spaces or moving between rooms. Gather a few relevant examples and identify the effect on access. Avoid assuming that an advanced vocabulary or a mature conversation means all language, social and organisational demands are equally manageable. Strengths and needs may differ within the same day and subject.
Listen without reinforcing expectations about girls
Create an opportunity for the pupil to discuss a particular task privately and accessibly. Ask what helped, what required effort and what they would change. Do not assume that a helpful, compliant pupil is comfortable, or that a pupil who expresses frustration is less credible. Gendered expectations about tidiness, sociability and pleasing adults can influence which behaviours staff notice and how they interpret them.
NHS and NICE guidance recognise under-recognition of ADHD in girls, while NHS autism guidance also describes less obvious presentations and masking. These are reasons to keep an open, informed view, not a basis for deciding that a particular high-attaining girl has either condition. Include other explanations and use appropriate assessment routes where concerns are significant. The pupil should receive support for observed needs without being required to match a stereotype first.
Compare school and family information carefully
Ask parents or carers for concrete examples of homework, preparation and recovery after the school day. A family may see effort or distress that is not visible during lessons. Staff may observe strengths and successful participation not seen at home. Treat the accounts as information about different circumstances and ask what conditions differ, rather than holding a contest over whose description is correct.
Be precise about adult support. A pupil may appear independent because a parent checks every resource each evening or because a teacher gives repeated private prompts. Record those contributions accurately when reviewing access. Do not remove effective support to provoke failure as proof of need. Instead, examine whether the current arrangement is reliable, appropriate and sustainable, and what teaching or provision is needed next.
Protect challenge while teaching insecure components
Identify which part of the task blocks access and adapt that part. A pupil with sophisticated historical understanding may need a clear planning model; a strong mathematician may need accessible instructions during a practical investigation. Maintain meaningful thinking rather than replacing every task with easier repetition. Check that an adjustment still allows the intended learning to be taught and demonstrated.
Teach an insecure component directly where appropriate. This might involve interpreting a success criterion, checking homework information or asking for clarification. Use an accessible example and planned practice, with a clear role for the adult. Avoid relying on a vague target to become more confident or organised. Describe the action being taught and how staff will recognise increasing control without removing necessary access support.
Coordinate provision and assessment questions
Bring the teacher, SENCo, pupil and family information together around a practical decision. Decide what will be changed, who is responsible and what evidence will inform review. Keep the record proportionate and distinguish an observation from an interpretation. A questionnaire score or a single work sample should not be treated as a diagnosis, nor should an overall attainment average obscure a clear difficulty in a different area.
If significant barriers persist despite suitable teaching and support, consider relevant specialist advice through the appropriate route. State the question that advice should answer. Where health or safeguarding concerns arise, follow those procedures alongside educational planning. Do not assume that a SEND label will resolve every concern or that the absence of a diagnosis justifies delaying all practical adjustments. Keep strengths, participation and wellbeing in the same conversation.
A fictional review example
A Year 8 pupil achieves strong English marks but routinely becomes distressed while preparing for collaborative presentations. Staff initially regard the concern as ordinary perfectionism. Conversation and observation show that roles change unpredictably and she cannot tell which contribution is expected. The teacher agrees explicit roles, models the planning sequence and provides a clear way to clarify a change. The pupil helps choose how the information is presented.
In this hypothetical example, review includes the quality of the contribution, participation, support needed and effort reported at home. Improvement may show that clearer teaching and arrangements help, without establishing a diagnosis or proving that no further need exists. If a barrier remains, the evidence becomes more specific for the next review. High attainment should remain a valued strength while decisions about SEND are informed by the pupil's actual access to education.
Further reading
- DfE and Department of Health: SEND Code of Practice
- Education Endowment Foundation: Special Educational Needs in Mainstream Schools
- NHS: ADHD in children and young people
- NHS: Signs of autism in children
Use these sources alongside professional judgement and the pupil’s individual context.
Share this article
Know someone who would find this useful?