Establish what has changed
Identify the subject, skill, period and evidence behind the concern. A lower test score, reduced work output, inaccurate recall and difficulty completing a familiar routine are different patterns. Compare with suitable previous evidence and check whether the task, marking, conditions or support changed. One difficult assessment should not carry a conclusion it cannot support.
Ask whether the change is sudden, persistent or limited to a particular context. Include strengths and tasks still managed. Avoid assuming loss of motivation, a new learning disorder or a consequence of an existing diagnosis. The first purpose is to understand the educational pattern accurately while recognising any concern that needs a prompt response outside routine classroom review.
Respond to health and safeguarding concerns
A new or marked change in functioning, distress, pain or other concerning signs should follow the appropriate school and health routes. Use urgent arrangements where there is an immediate concern; an attainment review is not a substitute for medical or safeguarding action. Teachers should not diagnose a cause from schoolwork or advise treatment beyond their role.
Listen privately if the pupil reports harm, fear or a significant difficulty. Follow relevant procedures and explain privacy and its limits. Do not require a complete account or proof that the issue caused the attainment change before a concern is taken seriously. Educational adjustments can proceed alongside responsible follow-up, with information shared proportionately.
Check opportunity to learn
Review attendance, missed explanations, curriculum changes and whether prerequisite knowledge was taught and understood. A pupil may appear to decline when new work introduces an unfamiliar concept or format. Identify what the current task requires rather than assume earlier success means all necessary foundations are secure.
Look at instruction, feedback and materials. Can the pupil locate the question, understand relevant vocabulary and identify a first step? Check whether an accessible format or model used previously has disappeared. A change in provision can affect performance without a change in underlying capacity. Record what was actually delivered and what the pupil could do with suitable teaching.
Separate knowledge from response demands
A pupil may know the content but struggle with handwriting, reading load, speech, organisation or time pressure. Use an appropriate accessible response to clarify the learning question, recognising that alternatives measure different components. An oral explanation can reveal subject reasoning without establishing independent written composition or spelling.
Check assistive technology, communication systems and relevant sensory or physical access. An unavailable device or inaccessible file may explain a particular failed opportunity, but do not generalise from one example. Follow existing professional recommendations and seek clarification where needed. Necessary support should remain available while the review determines whether the next step is teaching, adjustment or a focused professional question.
A fictional new-format assessment
In this fictional example, a pupil who usually explains scientific ideas well receives a much lower result in a written assessment. Staff initially worry that understanding has deteriorated. Review shows that the new paper combines dense text, unfamiliar question wording and an extended written response without the usual planning reference.
The teacher checks the relevant concepts through suitable discussion and a practical example, then teaches how the new question format works. Records distinguish understanding, response demands and help.
Include the pupil and family
Ask about specific recent tasks, effort, confidence and changes that may be relevant. Use an accessible conversation and allow time. The pupil may not know why performance has changed and should not be pressured into an explanation. Parents may describe information not visible at school, while staff can explain the classroom pattern concretely.
Keep the discussion respectful and proportionate. Avoid unnecessary personal enquiry or blame about home routines. Differences between accounts may reflect context, support and demand, so explore them rather than select the account that fits a preferred theory. Share what school will do next and whom the family can contact if new information or concerns arise.
Choose immediate teaching and follow-up
Select an action linked to the evidence, such as reteaching a missing concept, clarifying task language, restoring an aid or providing a usable feedback route. State who prepares it and what the pupil will experience. Avoid a generic programme added simply because a score fell, or repeated testing without a clear decision it will inform.
Where the pattern remains unexplained or persists, coordinate SENCo, pastoral and relevant professional input. Bring concrete comparisons, support information and the pupil’s account. Keep clinical and statutory questions within their appropriate processes. A planned review should not delay urgent action if functioning, safety or access deteriorates.
Compare the relevant component rather than the whole label
If a new assessment format coincides with lower attainment, examine which concept or response demand changed. Use a suitable task and accessible response to separate retained understanding from an unfamiliar instruction or recording requirement. Do not assume the whole decline has one explanation.
Record the teaching and assistance provided, then check a relevant new example later. If a usual support was absent, restore it appropriately while investigating any remaining learning gap. Welfare or health concerns still need their responsible response. The review should explain what the next teaching decision rests on, with limits clear, instead of using one improved or disappointing total as a verdict on the pupil’s overall ability.
Review the change and its limits
Use a small sample of relevant tasks over an agreed period, noting conditions, teaching, support and response. Check understanding and effort alongside marks or output. A return to a previous score may be reassuring but does not automatically show that every barrier has resolved, while one continued low result does not establish a fixed decline.
Retain useful support and explain the next decision to the pupil and family. State what remains uncertain and who follows it up. Good review avoids both premature reassurance and an unsupported diagnosis. It should restore meaningful access to learning and provide a clearer account of the change, rather than make the pupil repeatedly demonstrate difficulty before adults respond.
Further reading
This source provides background guidance. The examples and review suggestions above are original classroom illustrations to adapt, rather than evaluated programmes or diagnostic tests.
These articles offer general guidance for school staff. They do not assess or diagnose an individual child or replace advice based on that child’s circumstances. Use professional judgement and your school’s policies when deciding what support is appropriate.
Share this article
Know someone who would find this useful?