When differentiated work appears to increase reliance on adults, school should review the teaching arrangement rather than assume differentiation itself is harmful or the pupil needs less support. The work may be inaccessible without explanation, disconnected from class teaching or organised so that an adult supplies each decision. A parent conversation should identify what the pupil is learning and what the assistance enables.
The aim is suitable challenge, access and growing agency. Necessary communication, care, physical or safety support must remain dependable. Independence cannot be judged only by whether an adult is nearby. At the same time, adults should examine whether the current materials and interaction give the pupil opportunities to understand, choose, practise and apply their own skills.
Define the differentiated task
Explain the intended learning and how the task differs from the class activity. Is the concept, vocabulary, format, volume or level of support adapted? A separate worksheet is not automatically more accessible, and simpler-looking work may still contain an unclear instruction. Parents need a concrete example rather than a broad assurance that the task matches the pupil’s level.
Ask about the pupil’s account and comparable work at home. Do they understand the purpose, know how to start and recognise when help is needed? Differences between settings can reveal useful supports. Avoid asking parents to prove independence or implying that home assistance has caused a school-based problem without evidence.
Check access to the teacher’s explanation
Observe whether the pupil hears and understands relevant class teaching or receives a separate explanation later from another adult. EEF guidance on TA deployment emphasises access to high-quality teaching with teachers retaining responsibility for all pupils. A TA should not be left to invent a parallel curriculum from unfamiliar materials.
For example, a pupil may be given different questions that use a method not shown in the teacher’s model. They then wait for an adult to explain every item. The issue may concern the connection between teaching and task, not a general reluctance to work. Clarify the intended approach and prepare suitable resources and staff communication.
Separate knowledge from task management
Assess what the pupil understands and what other demands interfere. Reading instructions, locating materials, recording and organising steps can obscure subject knowledge. An adult may be providing essential access in one area while the pupil works independently in another. Record those functions accurately rather than treating all assistance as the same thing.
For instance, a pupil may solve a mathematical problem after an accessible explanation but need physical support to record it. Another may write fluently while needing the concept taught. These situations require different plans. Removing the adult in both cases would not clarify which skill has been learned or what support remains necessary.
Examine prompts and decisions
Look at what happens when the pupil pauses. Does the adult immediately provide the answer, identify the next step, ask a useful question or wait without noticing an access problem? The effect depends on the pupil’s needs and task. Neither constant prompting nor unsupported waiting is automatically appropriate.
Agree a focused teaching step and suitable assistance. The pupil might learn to use a worked example, locate the first instruction or check one feature. Model and practise the action in the relevant context. A reminder to be independent does not explain how to perform it, and a checklist is not useful unless the pupil understands when and how to use it.
Review challenge and participation
Ask whether the adapted task retains worthwhile learning or has become repetitive occupation. A pupil may complete easy work with an adult while missing the concepts peers are being taught. Conversely, a task may be too difficult despite superficial simplification. Use current evidence and teaching to identify an appropriate starting point.
Include the pupil’s views about materials, grouping and adult interaction. They may find a separate resource helpful, embarrassing or confusing. Respect their perspective without assuming that every individual adjustment is unwelcome. Review peer participation and access to shared learning so that differentiation does not unnecessarily isolate the pupil from the class.
Coordinate adults and relevant plans
Teachers and support staff need a shared understanding of the learning aim, likely difficulty and appropriate response. Leadership may need to address preparation time, training or resources. Do not make a single TA responsible for a pattern created by wider deployment decisions. Parents should hear what school will change, not only what the pupil is expected to do.
Where formal provision or specialist advice applies, use the relevant process before making a consequential change. An informal wish to increase independence does not authorise withdrawing required assistance. Clarify any uncertainty with the appropriate lead while maintaining educational access and safety.
Review learning rather than adult distance
Choose meaningful evidence: the pupil’s explanation, use of a taught strategy, appropriate help-seeking or application to a new example. Include effort and comfort alongside completed work. Fewer adult minutes are not sufficient evidence if the pupil is left confused or no longer participates. More visible assistance may still support greater agency when it enables the pupil’s own decisions.
Check whether agreed teaching and preparation occurred before judging the response. Share concise findings with parents and refine the plan. Effective discussion makes differentiation a reasoned route into learning, with adult support reviewed by its purpose and effect rather than removed or continued automatically because the pupil has always received it.
Compare the pupil’s performance on a carefully selected new example, with the support conditions recorded. Repeating the same adapted worksheet may show familiarity rather than flexible understanding. Teachers can use that information to decide whether to teach the concept again, make instructions clearer or offer another suitable practice opportunity. Parents should receive the distinction plainly, so that a completed task is neither overstated as full independence nor dismissed as having no value.
Further reading
Use external guidance alongside information about the individual pupil and your school context.
Share this article
Know someone who would find this useful?