Find the part of the story that is hard to follow
A pupil who struggles to tell a coherent story may have plenty to say but find it difficult to select events, order them or explain their connections. More words do not necessarily make an account clearer. Begin with a familiar, low-pressure event and listen for what the audience needs to know. The aim is an understandable message with a purpose, rather than a long performance judged mainly by fluency or the number of details included.
Notice whether the listener can identify who was involved, where events happened, what changed and how the account ends. Check pronouns, time words and links such as because, after and so. The pupil may assume the listener shares information that has not been explained. Record a short example and the prompts used, while respecting privacy. A familiar event may be easier than an invented narrative, so compare the demands rather than treating all storytelling tasks as equivalent.
Separate narrative structure from other barriers
Check vocabulary, sentence understanding and the pupil's knowledge of the event. They may lose the sequence while searching for a word or find it hard to explain causes they have not understood. Consider memory, attention and response mode without making diagnostic assumptions. For multilingual pupils, explore relevant language experience and, where feasible, storytelling in their other languages. Difficulty producing an English account alone does not establish a wider language disorder.
Keep the content emotionally safe. Do not use a distressing incident as routine narrative practice or repeatedly question a child about a possible safeguarding disclosure. Follow the school's safeguarding procedures when concerns arise, using an appropriate response rather than coaching a polished version. A disordered account does not establish that a pupil is unreliable or untruthful. Staff need to distinguish language support for learning from the handling of sensitive information.
Give the account a clear purpose and listener
Choose a reason to tell the story: explain a class activity to an absent pupil, describe a familiar journey or retell a short fictional event. Ask what that listener already knows and what must be supplied. This helps the pupil decide which details matter. Avoid an unlimited instruction to “tell me everything”, which can create a large selection and organisation demand before the child has a useful structure.
Use a small number of picture, object or word prompts where helpful. Show the main events in order and discuss the connection between them. Do not assume that arranging pictures automatically teaches a coherent explanation; the pupil also needs language and understanding to connect the scenes. Invite pointing, drawing or a communication aid if speech makes it difficult to show the sequence. Keep the learning goal focused enough for success to be visible.
Model a short, connected account
Demonstrate an account that includes the essential setting, event and outcome. Explain briefly why a missing detail would confuse a listener. For example, name the person before using “she” and show how “because” explains a reason rather than merely adding another event. Keep the model manageable and natural. A highly elaborate adult story may be harder to learn from than a concise example with clear connections.
Invite the pupil to improve an incomplete fictional account. Ask which person or event needs explaining and how two parts are linked. This can make the listener's needs visible without immediately judging the pupil's own experience. Then help them construct a short account using familiar content. Provide direct teaching where needed rather than asking a chain of vague questions until they guess which detail the adult wants.
Rehearse the structure before increasing length
Practise the beginning, important change and ending, then add a relevant explanation or detail. Use connecting words in meaningful contexts and compare how they change the account. “After” establishes order; “because” supplies a reason, and the relationship needs to make sense. Avoid rewarding the use of a particular word when it joins unrelated ideas. A short coherent account is a stronger foundation than a longer one with many unconnected events.
For example, a pupil describes a playground game by naming several children and actions without explaining what happened. Staff use three simple prompts to identify the original game, the change and how it ended. The pupil then explains the account to an adult who was not present. The listener asks one genuine clarification question. Later, the pupil tries a different familiar event, so success is not limited to a single rehearsed story.
Reduce prompts while keeping access available
Move from adult-led questions towards a prompt the pupil can consult themselves. Teach when to pause and consider whether the listener has enough information. A simple structure card may remain useful during classroom explanations, provided the pupil understands and chooses it. Do not remove communication support merely to create an unsupported test of independence. At the same time, record when an adult supplies an event, word or causal link so the performance is interpreted accurately.
Coordinate with teachers and support staff so the routine appears in ordinary learning, not only a separate session. It may help with explaining a practical investigation, recounting a visit or planning writing. Adapt it to the subject and age. Older pupils need respectful materials and opportunities to express their own ideas; a basic narrative structure should not become a permanently restricted expectation for the complexity of their thinking.
Review clarity on a fresh event
Ask for a new account and check whether the pupil independently supplies essential information, orders events and explains relevant links. Include the listener's understanding and the pupil's experience, not just length or speed. Persistent difficulties across communication and learning deserve discussion with the SENCo and family, with speech and language advice where appropriate. RCSLT resources provide wider context for communication needs. Progress means a more effective message and greater control over how to make it understandable to another person.
Sources for this article
Further reading
Use these sources alongside current local procedures, professional advice and the individual pupil’s circumstances.
Share this article
Know someone who would find this useful?