Look for the barrier
Bring together the pupil's strengths, work samples, response to teaching, attendance, language background, pupil and family views, and progress over time. Specify where learning breaks down and which adjustments have already been tried. Ask what decision an assessment would inform.
An assessment is most useful when it answers a question that current teaching and review have not resolved. A low score on one task or a request for a label may not show which provision the pupil needs. Gather dated examples of work, strengths, response to teaching, language and attendance context, and the pupil and family's views. Identify where learning breaks down and what changes when support is adjusted.
Frame the question around decisions the assessment could inform. Gather work samples, teaching history, attendance and the pupil's and family's views; note what has been tried, for how long and with what response. Discuss what remains uncertain with the SENCo. The route to advice depends on local arrangements and the question being asked, so the school should explain the proposed referral and seek the relevant consent and involvement. A low score on its own should never be the whole referral story.
What to try in school
Discuss the pattern with the SENCo and family, then choose an appropriate professional or pathway for the question. An educational psychologist may explore learning processes and context; speech and language, sensory, medical or other specialists may be relevant for different concerns. Continue support while waiting.
Write a referral question that can guide action. 'Why can the pupil explain number ideas with objects but not apply them in written calculations?' is more useful than 'Assess for a difficulty.' Discuss it with the SENCo and family and choose a professional or pathway suited to that question. Educational psychology, speech and language, sensory or health involvement may be relevant in different cases. Continue proportionate teaching adjustments while a referral is considered.
Before seeking specialist advice, write down the exact decision that remains difficult. It might concern why reading teaching has produced little transfer, which adjustments support access or whether several areas of learning need fuller exploration. Include examples of what the pupil can do under different conditions, not only a list of difficulties. Agree with the family and pupil how their views will be represented. The assessment may clarify a pattern, but school staff still need to translate any recommendations into ordinary lesson practice and review whether the pupil participates and learns. Set a date for that review rather than waiting for another formal report.
A worked example
A Year 5 pupil completes mental calculations in conversation but makes repeated place-value errors on paper. The teacher collects two dated examples, observes the pupil using tens and ones, and tries explicit teaching with drawings and written notation. The pupil improves with objects but cannot explain the written step after repeated practice. The team asks a focused question about the relationship between conceptual understanding and written recording and agrees what an assessment would need to clarify for teaching.
Review what changes
Review the outcome by asking whether the assessment led to clearer teaching and provision. Do not wait for a diagnosis before making reasonable classroom adjustments.
Review whether any assessment actually changes understanding, provision or the pupil's access to learning. Record what was recommended, who will deliver it and how progress will be checked. A diagnosis by itself does not replace effective teaching, and lack of one should not prevent support for observed needs.
Keep teaching and support going while advice is sought. The review can ask whether specialist information changed the understanding of the barrier, the teaching plan or access to the curriculum. If it did not, revisit the referral question rather than waiting for a label to make support possible. Share findings in plain language with the pupil and family, including what school will do, who will do it and when the next review will occur.
What does the evidence tell us?
The SEND code of practice places assessment within a graduated process of identifying needs, providing support and reviewing outcomes. EEF SEND guidance stresses knowing the pupil and using effective teaching. Neither suggests withholding classroom adjustments while waiting for specialist input or inferring a diagnosis from one low result.
Further reading
Use this resource to explore the wider evidence and adapt ideas to the pupil and school context.
Share this article
Know someone who would find this useful?