How do we know whether an intervention is actually making a difference?

Look for credible improvement on the intended skill, sustained beyond practised examples and useful in ordinary learning. Progress after an intervention is encouraging, but does not by itself prove that the intervention caused it.

Make comparisons meaningful

Keep a starting sample and use comparable new material at review. Record task difficulty and adult help. Repeating the identical questions can show familiarity, while a much harder assessment may obscure genuine progress.

Look for a pattern

For example, a pupil learning to blend words can try unfamiliar words using the taught patterns at several points. Compare accuracy and the support needed, then inspect relevant classroom reading. A single unusually good session should not carry the whole conclusion.

Check other explanations

Review attendance, delivery and changes in class teaching or support. An apparent improvement may partly reflect easier tasks or additional prompts. Conversely, limited classroom change may indicate that the taught skill has not yet been connected to lesson demands.

Make the next decision explicit

Bring the evidence together with pupil experience and the cost in curriculum time. Record whether to continue, alter a particular component or stop and replace the approach. Explain uncertainty honestly; routine school monitoring informs decisions without providing a controlled evaluation.

Further reading

This source provides wider teaching guidance. The examples and review suggestions above are original classroom illustrations to adapt, rather than evaluated programmes or diagnostic tests.

More practical advice: Browse the advice.

Share this article

Know someone who would find this useful?