Checking intervention fidelity means examining whether the important elements of an intervention were delivered as intended. Without that information, limited progress can be mistaken for evidence that the approach is ineffective, while a modified version may be described as though the original programme was tested. Good provision makes delivery understandable without creating excessive monitoring. The purpose is to improve the fit between need, teaching and implementation, then judge the pupil’s response fairly. Fidelity is one part of evaluation, not proof of benefit by itself.
Clarify the intended approach
Identify the intervention, its purpose and the pupil’s starting need. State which elements are important to the rationale: content, sequence, instructional routine, practice, feedback or another specified feature. Use the programme’s current guidance and relevant evidence rather than assuming a resource’s name explains its delivery. A worksheet collection and a structured teaching sequence should not be treated as equivalent simply because both target the same broad skill.
Check that the approach is suitable for the pupil and context. A faithfully delivered programme can still be a poor match for the barrier. The EEF’s intervention and implementation guidance supports attention to selection, preparation, delivery and review. Use that framework to ask practical questions rather than turn fidelity into a compliance exercise detached from learning. Necessary communication, sensory and other access arrangements should remain in view.
Record planned and actual delivery
Keep a manageable account of relevant content, session frequency, duration, group size and staff role. Note attendance, interruptions and substantial departures from the plan. The record should show what happened, not simply repeat the timetable. If sessions were frequently cancelled, state that honestly. Limited progress after inconsistent delivery raises a different decision from limited progress after reliable, appropriate teaching.
Avoid excessive minute-by-minute forms unless a specific purpose requires them. Staff need enough information to interpret outcomes and identify a practical issue. A short record linked to the important elements may be more useful than a detailed log no one reviews. Explain why the information is collected and who will use it. Recording should support delivery rather than consume the time needed to prepare and teach.
Check staff preparation and resources
Ask whether the adult understands the instructional sequence, feedback and use of materials. Provide relevant training and a route for questions. A brief handover may not establish competence in a specialist approach. Do not assume that an experienced teaching assistant automatically knows an unfamiliar programme or that a teacher can infer its essential components from the pupil booklet alone.
Review practical conditions: appropriate space, materials, timing and coordination with lessons. A noisy shared area or repeated interruptions can change the teaching opportunity substantially. If the arrangement cannot support the intended delivery, address the system rather than blame the adult or pupil. Senior staff and the SENCo may need to resolve timetable or resource barriers that an individual session leader cannot control.
Distinguish adaptation from accidental drift
Some changes are necessary to make an intervention accessible or workable. Record what changed and why, and consider whether the important instructional features remain. Seek relevant programme or professional advice where needed. Do not preserve an inaccessible method merely to claim fidelity, but do not assume every convenient change retains the same evidence base. Be honest about what version was delivered.
Examples might include a different communication format, altered materials or a change in group size. Their significance depends on the intervention and purpose. A minor presentation change may differ from removing the feedback or replacing the teaching sequence. The review should identify what matters to the approach rather than count every variation as equally serious. Keep the pupil’s access and dignity central to the decision.
Sample practice proportionately
A supportive observation or discussion can clarify delivery beyond a session count. Agree its purpose and look at the relevant teaching actions, resources and pupil response. Avoid treating a short visit as proof that every session is identical. Use several information sources where proportionate and note limits. The aim is a fair understanding that helps staff improve, not a performance judgement based on an unusual day.
An illustrative reading intervention shows little change after several weeks. The timetable suggests regular delivery, but a review identifies cancellations and a replacement activity that omitted the intended decoding practice. Staff clarify training, restore reliable teaching and record the actual content. They establish a suitable point for the next review rather than conclude that the pupil cannot benefit from the approach. Any ongoing access support remains available while the instructional plan is corrected.
Evaluate outcomes separately
Use suitable information about the intended skill and its application in ordinary learning. Fidelity answers what was delivered; outcome evaluation asks what changed and at what cost. A fully delivered intervention may need replacing if it does not meet the need, while an apparently positive result still needs cautious interpretation. Avoid claiming that one pupil’s improvement proves the programme caused it when other teaching and circumstances also changed.
Agree a next decision: improve delivery, refine access, strengthen classroom links, change the approach or seek relevant advice. Consider curriculum time, effort and the pupil’s experience alongside progress. Follow appropriate processes where provision is formally specified. Useful fidelity checking makes implementation visible enough to support a reasoned decision, keeping the emphasis on effective teaching and meaningful participation rather than the completion of a monitoring checklist.
Agree how a staffing change will be managed. A new adult may need preparation, observation or support before continuing the teaching sequence. Record the change so that a later review does not treat different delivery conditions as though nothing altered.
Use these sources alongside current local procedures, professional advice and the individual pupil’s circumstances.
Share this article
Know someone who would find this useful?