Check the current approach before changing it
Compare what happens when the pupil checks meaning, spelling and punctuation separately. Ask them to show what they think 'edit' means; they may understand it as copying everything again.
Check that the agreed teaching occurred, that instructions and materials were accessible and that the task actually measured the intended skill. Distinguish a poor fit from a plan that was not delivered consistently.
Change the part that is not helping
Keep composition and editing as separate stages. Ask the pupil to improve one feature of a short passage, rather than correct every error in a completed page.
Model rereading one sentence aloud, deciding whether it communicates the intended idea and changing one part. Give a narrow checklist that matches what has actually been taught. Preserve the pupil's wording where it works.
Test a purposeful adjustment
For example, agree to check sentence endings in just the first three sentences. The adult demonstrates one, shares the next and lets the pupil check the third.
Keep a note of the specific change, the support provided and what the pupil could do. Where possible, keep other task demands similar so staff can interpret the response.
Decide what to retain or replace
Count useful corrections made without an adult pointing to the error. Also note whether the pupil can explain why the change helps the reader.
Continue useful support, revise an approach that produces no meaningful benefit and involve the SENCo when the explanation remains unclear. Do not continue a distressing or inaccessible activity merely to complete a programme.
Further reading
Use these sources alongside current local procedures, professional advice and the individual pupil’s circumstances.
Share this article
Know someone who would find this useful?